In a heated session on Saturday, the Texas House of Representatives advanced House Bill 229, also known as the ‘Women’s Bill of Rights,’ which aims to strictly define men and women based on their assigned reproductive organs at birth. The bill, authored by Republican Representative Ellen Troxclair of Austin, passed a second reading with a vote of 86-36 and is poised to move to the Senate next week.
If enacted into law, this bill would mandate that state records reflect the binary definition of sex as determined by reproductive anatomy at birth. This means that more than 120,000 transgender Texans who have legally changed their documents would be forced to revert to their birth-assigned gender on official records, regardless of their current legal gender markers.
During the debate, Troxclair, surrounded by a group of Republican women, framed the bill as essential to preserving women’s rights from being ‘eroded by activists’ as more individuals identify as transgender or nonbinary. ‘We’re a state that believes in truth, and we’re a state that honors the hard-won achievements of women,’ Troxclair stated on the House floor. ‘But if we can no longer define what a woman is, we cannot defend what women have won.’
However, Democratic lawmakers and LGBTQ+ advocates decried the bill as harmful and deeply disrespectful to transgender Texans. Representative Jessica González, a Democrat from Dallas, criticized the bill as ‘harmful, dangerous, and really freaking insulting,’ emphasizing the personal impact on trans and nonbinary residents whose legal documents would be invalidated.
The debate over HB 229 reflects an ongoing battle within Texas and across the United States about how to define gender in legal and societal contexts. For conservative lawmakers, the answer hinges on biological characteristics, while for transgender advocates and allies, it is a matter of personal identity and lived experience.
This contentious issue mirrors national trends, as seen in a recent survey where nearly half of Americans expressed support for restrictive transgender policies championed by figures like former President Donald Trump. The push for legally enshrining gender based on birth anatomy follows a series of legislative measures nationwide targeting transgender rights, from youth sports bans to restrictions on healthcare access.
RELATED: Half of Americans Back Trump’s Stance on Transgender Issues
The Bottom Line
While Republican lawmakers frame such measures as safeguarding women’s rights, transgender advocates argue that these bills are an attack on fundamental identity and personal freedom. As the bill moves to the Senate, the voices of transgender Texans and their allies remain strong, as demonstrated by a recent rally at the Capitol where protestors defiantly chanted, ‘They will not erase us.’
The passage of HB 229 would mark a significant shift in how Texas legally recognizes gender, challenging the autonomy of transgender individuals in the state. For many, the prospect of having their identity erased by state records is not just a legislative issue but a deeply personal attack.
TransVitae will continue to follow this story as it unfolds, providing updates and perspectives from the transgender community and allies. Stay informed as we track the progression of this bill and its potential impact on the lives of thousands of Texans.
